
Hyung-Gu Lynn
The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada
Keywords: policy analysis, comparative public policy, interdisciplinarity, Asia and the Pacific, mountaineering
DOI: 10.5509/2025983-art7
POLICY ANALYSIS IN SOUTH KOREA. Edited by T. J. Lah and Thomas R. Klassen. International Library of Policy Analysis. Bristol: Policy Press, 2023. 316 pp. US$46.00, ebook. ISBN 9781447362579.
POLICY ANALYSIS IN THAILAND. Edited by Ora-orn Poocharoen and Piyapong Boossabong. International Library of Policy Analysis. Bristol: Policy Press, 2023. 356 pp. US$39.00, ebook. ISBN 9781447367093.
POLICY ANALYSIS IN JAPAN. Edited by Yukio Adachi, Sukehiro Hosono, and Jun Iio. International Library of Policy Analysis. Bristol: Policy Press, 2015. 352 pp. US$52.00, ebook. ISBN 9781447347415.
POLICY ANALYSIS IN CANADA. Edited by Laurent Dobuzinskis and Michael Howlett. International Library of Policy Analysis. Bristol: Policy Press, 2018. 352 pp. US$35.00, ebook. ISBN 9781447346043.
POLICY ANALYSIS IN AUSTRALIA. Edited by Brian Head and Kate Crowley. International Library of Policy Analysis. Bristol: Policy Press, 2015. 336 pp. US$52.00, ebook. ISBN 9781447347491.
POLICY ANALYSIS IN TAIWAN. Edited by Yu-Ying Kuo. International Library of Policy Analysis. Bristol: Policy Press, 2015. 268 pp. US$52.00, ebook. ISBN 9781447347453.
This essay reviews six volumes from the Policy Press International Library of Policy Analysisseries, focusing on policy analysis in South Korea, Japan, Taiwan, Thailand, Canada, and Australia. Using a mountaineering metaphor, the essay highlights the challenging and varied terrains of policy analysis within each nation. Each book systematically maps the distinct national policy landscapes, addressing the roles, techniques, influences, and guiding norms of policy actors in government, academia, and civil society. The first part summarizes the key insights from each volume, looking at their common coverage areas, as well as their treatments of more endemic policy issues and subjects. The second part of the essay proposes future research avenues across six rubrics: inter-disciplinary, inter-method, inter-typology, inter-domain, inter-temporal, and inter-linguistic. These suggestions aim to fuel future insights by encouraging broader and deeper conversations with related academic fields; re-assessments of analytical tools; strategic applications of existing conceptual typologies; strategic diversifications of coverage of key policy areas; further incorporations of nuanced historical analysis; and additional engagements with diverse linguistic sources. This review essay thus underscores the series’ important contributions to comparative public policy and identifies possibilities for future explorations into the complexities of governance and policy studies.
书评
政策分析的巅峰:亚太地区的六个国家案例
关键词: 政策分析、比较公共政策、跨学科、亚太地区、登山运动
本文评述了Policy出版社国际政策分析图书馆系列丛书的六卷,重点关注韩国、日本、台湾、泰国、加拿大和澳大利亚的政策分析。文章以登山者的比喻,勾勒出各卷书的内容及其在各卷书内部和跨卷书之间的相对缺失。第二部分重点介绍了一些相对匮乏的领域,并将它们标记为未来的研究方向,涵盖六个方面:跨学科、跨方法、跨类型、跨领域、跨时间和跨语言。这些建议旨在鼓励与相关学科进行更广泛、更深入的对话;系统地重新评估分析工具;集中应用概念类型学;有计划地、战略性地多样化对关键政策领域的覆盖;进一步融入精准的历史分析;以及与不同语言来源的更多合作。因此,这篇评论文章强调了该系列丛书对比较公共政策的重要贡献,并指出了未来探索治理和政策研究复杂性的可能性。